Personalized Insurance

Sheffield Lake, OH's trusted insurance company

Welcome to Custis Insurance Services Inc. We're a local company in Sheffield Lake, OH, bringing over 60 years of experience to Lorain County and Western Cuyahoga County. Our team gives you the personal attention you deserve and works hard to secure the best possible rates from the national companies you know and trust to find the perfect policy for you.

Our history

We aren't strangers to Sheffield Lake, OH -- Custis Insurance Service Inc has been in business for over 60 years right here in Lorain County. You can't miss our small-town-attention feel and personalized service. As an independent agency our team always goes the extra mile for our friends, neighbors, and community here in Ohio.

Talk to us

Don't hesitate to call our team at (440) 949-7171 or stop by our office to get more familiar with our coverage options. Because we can help with personal and commercial insurance policies, we have a lot of information that we're happy to guide you through step by step.

Our business

Custis Insurance Service Inc is a proud member of Strategic Independent Insurance Alliance, which includes Travelers, Hartford, Grange and Westfield. We're also happy to offer further coverage from national brands you know, like Progressive, AAA, and Safeco, all with our own personalized care and attention.
Female agent helping family to obtain insurance
Tammie Gerding
Karen Custis Bockelman
Karen Bockelman
Tammie Gerding 

Find your policy today.

Share by: